Skip to content
2026 black friday Save up to $525 OFF on select 3D scanning systems through Nov 30 View active offers now
SKYLAB3D

Search the catalog

CATALOG / PROCUREMENT

Accessory quote list

Review accessory quantities and compatibility before preparing your itemized PDF quote. Scanner systems are configured in Configurator Studio.

Add accessories from the catalog, or choose a scanner to start a system configuration.

Browse Accessories ↗Choose a Scanner ↗

FreeScan Combo+ Wireless handheld 3D scanner on a blue manufacturer overview graphic

Technical review: SKYLAB3D Technical Team

CMM vs 3D Scanner: Divide the Inspection Work

If your CMM is the bottleneck, replacing it is not the only option. First identify which inspection work needs its established measurement routine and which work would benefit from dense surface data collected elsewhere.

A handheld 3D scanner can help a quality team investigate shape, compare accessible surfaces with CAD, and inspect parts that are awkward to bring to a measuring room. It does not automatically take over every dimension on the drawing. The useful buying question is: which characteristics can move to a validated scanning process without weakening the acceptance decision?

Define what you mean by CMM and scanner

This comparison concerns a fixed CMM using a tactile probe and a portable optical surface scanner. The categories are not opposites: CMMs can also use optical sensors, and tactile scanning probes can collect continuous measurements. ZEISS's CMM sensor range illustrates these different configurations.

Compare the actual systems and measurement tasks, not the labels alone. A touch-trigger routine measuring selected features, a tactile scanning routine evaluating form, and a handheld mesh capture are different processes. None should be assumed to provide the same evidence merely because all produce coordinates.

Assign the work before comparing equipment

Take one representative drawing and mark the characteristics that cause delays or uncertainty. Use the following allocation as a starting point for testing, not as an automatic acceptance plan.

Where each inspection task should be evaluated
Inspection task Route to evaluate What must be demonstrated
Broad external shape or local distortion Optical scanning for dense coverage and CAD comparison. Coverage of the required surfaces, appropriate alignment, and usable data on the production finish.
Critical bores and datum features Retain the proven CMM or gage routine while evaluating any proposed transfer. Feature access, sampling, repeatability, and measurement uncertainty suitable for the requirement.
Large or difficult-to-move workpieces Portable scanning or another appropriate portable measurement system. Performance across the required volume, a stable reference, and control of the actual environment.
A repeated production acceptance check Compare the complete existing routine with the proposed scanning routine. Time to an approved result, operator involvement, repeatability, and the handling of exceptions.
A surface hidden from optical view An accessible probe, suitable gage, or another qualified method. Actual access to the characteristic. A filled mesh hole is not a measurement of the missing surface.

Keep the comparison tied to the same requirement

Consider an illustrative cast housing with a broad outside profile and two precision bores. Surface scanning may reveal where the casting departs from CAD, while an established contact routine remains responsible for the bores. The resulting report should make that division explicit instead of presenting a single color map as proof that every characteristic passed.

When the methods disagree, first check whether they evaluated the same feature, datum reference, sampling region, and fitting method. A global best-fit surface comparison and a drawing-based datum alignment can answer different questions. Investigate those differences before treating either number as the reference truth.

NIST's traceability guidance explains that traceability belongs to a measurement result, not simply to an instrument or its calibration certificate. Traceability also does not establish that the uncertainty is adequate for the intended purpose.

Agree on how measurement uncertainty will enter the acceptance decision. ASME lists B89.7.3.1 guidance on decision rules for determining conformance to specifications. Apply the requirements agreed with your customer and quality organization; there is no universal scanner-to-tolerance ratio that approves every application.

For the distinction between equipment accuracy, point spacing, and repeatability, use SKYLAB3D's 3D scanner accuracy versus resolution guide.

Time the complete inspection, including the difficult steps

Scanning speed is only one part of the comparison. A short capture can still leave substantial work in preparation, alignment, feature extraction, reporting, or checking missing data. An existing CMM routine may already have those steps established.

For a representative trial, record these stages separately:

  • Preparation: moving and stabilizing the part, fixturing, calibration checks, markers, and any permitted surface preparation.
  • Measurement: the defined CMM routine or scan acquisition, including repositioning and repeat captures.
  • Evaluation: alignment, feature construction, the required dimensional results, and report preparation.
  • Exceptions: missing surfaces, uncertain features, independent checks, and any work sent back to another instrument.

Repeat the trial with the people and conditions expected in production. Record elapsed time and operator time separately. Keep both the successful results and the exceptions; they define the real capacity that the proposed process can take over. Do not convert a manufacturer's points-per-second specification into a promised inspection-cycle saving.

Where FreeScan Combo+ Wireless fits

FreeScan Combo+ Wireless for portable metrology capture is one option to evaluate when accessible surface coverage and movement around the part are priorities. The official Shining 3D specification lists 93 laser lines in high-speed mode, 25 parallel lines for detailed capture, a single-line mode for accessible deep pockets, and built-in video photogrammetry.

Those features do not remove line-of-sight limits or establish that every bore, edge, or tolerance can transfer from the CMM. Confirm the exact model, mode, reference setup, and applicable calibration documentation during the evaluation. The wired Combo+ and Combo+ Wireless are separate products.

FreeScan capture software is included. Inspection software and its license are a separate configuration decision; confirm the required analysis and reporting tools in the quote rather than assuming that capture software includes every inspection function.

Use SKYLAB3D's industrial inspection system guidance and industrial and metrology scanner range to review the wider equipment options. If Combo+ Wireless fits the proposed optical tasks, plan a demo around those inspection characteristics.

Products discussed in this guide

Frequently asked questions

Can a 3D scanner replace a CMM?

It may take over selected inspection tasks after the proposed process is validated. It is not a universal replacement. Keep established contact or other measurement methods for characteristics that require them because of access, uncertainty, customer requirements, or production needs.

Is a CMM always more accurate than a 3D scanner?

No blanket ranking applies to every system and task. Compare the actual equipment, measurement volume, feature, environment, and complete process uncertainty. CMMs can use tactile or optical sensors, so define the configuration being compared.

Is 3D scanning faster than CMM inspection?

It can be useful for dense surface capture, but capture speed alone does not establish a faster inspection. Measure the complete time for preparation, acquisition, evaluation, reporting, and exceptions on representative work.

Does FreeScan Combo+ Wireless include all inspection software?

FreeScan capture software is included. Confirm the inspection software, license, analysis functions, and reporting requirements separately in the quoted configuration.

Filed in: CMM vs 3D scanner, dimensional inspection, FreeScan Combo+ Wireless, inspection planning, metrology

Compare products

{"one"=>"Select 2 or 3 items to compare", "other"=>"{{ count }} of 3 items selected"}

Select first item to compare

Select second item to compare

Select third item to compare

Compare